Meta's attempt to push back against one of its most effective critics has produced an unusual sight: academics who have spent years dismantling Jonathan Haidt's arguments are now rushing to defend him — from Meta.
Court filings in California, disclosed last month as part of consolidated lawsuits accusing Meta and other social media companies of misleading the public about the risks their products pose to teenagers, show that Meta employees discussed in 2023 what they called a “Whisper strategy” to “turn academics against Haidt”. The notes floated a “Below-the-line campaign”, including the idea to “Get Gellman to write a take-down piece” — an apparent reference to Andrew Gelman, a Columbia University professor of statistics and political science who had already publicly criticised Haidt's methods. It is not clear whether Meta ever acted on the plan. Meta declined to comment.
Haidt, author of The Anxious Generation, has argued for years that smartphones and social media are a major cause of the decline in teen mental health. Since the disclosure, the reaction has run in a direction Meta probably did not anticipate. Candice Odgers, a psychology professor and one of Haidt's most persistent critics, published a Substack post titled “No. I was not paid to critique the Anxious Generation”, writing that she “came to the conclusion that the science featured in it was flawed all on my own” and had never been approached by Meta.
danah boyd of Cornell University, who has studied how teenagers use social media, wrote that she now has “absolutely nothing nice to say about Meta-the-company” and considers it “unethical to the core” — while standing by her own research. Gelman, whose name appears to be in the meeting notes, told The Verge that he has never been contacted by anyone at Facebook or Meta about Haidt. He has received money from the company in the past, including a $25,000 no-strings donation in 2016, but never for work on teen health. Calling behind-the-scenes influence “creepy”, he added that Meta has every right to make its case in public.
Chris Ferguson of Stetson University, who published a meta-analysis finding limited evidence of a causal link between social media and poorer mental health, was blunter still: he accused both Haidt and Meta of being “more similar than different”, aggressive and a “pernicious influence” on the science — and said it is possible to see Meta as “big, ugly, cynical and unethical” and Haidt as overstating the evidence at the same time.
Haidt said he has never suggested that any of the researchers named were paid by Meta, and welcomed the criticism as part of rigorous scientific debate. But he drew a line between the scientific dispute and the company's tactics: Meta's own internal studies, he said, confirm his findings, and its internal documents show a plan to distort the academic debate — “a tactic straight out of the Big Tobacco playbook”.
The litigation is already expensive for Meta. The company has suffered several high-profile legal defeats in similar cases that could cost it billions of dollars, and it separately settled claims brought by state attorneys general for $17.1 billion.




