Brazil's Superior Electoral Court (TSE) fined Meta 7.5 million real (about €1.2 million) on Tuesday, ruling unanimously that the company failed to comply with court orders meant to guarantee fair treatment of the two presidential campaigns in last month's runoff.
The case centered on accusations that Meta treated incumbent Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and challenger Flávio Bolsonaro unequally — restricting the reach of Lula's posts while making Bolsonaro's more visible. Meta denied the allegations but acknowledged technical "incidents" and told the court before the October 25 runoff that it had taken steps to ensure equal treatment.
Judge Marco Aurélio Bellizze wrote that the record contained technical flaws Facebook itself had admitted, but said there was no indication, at this preliminary stage, that the company deliberately tried to disturb the electoral balance. Such a conclusion would require solid evidence produced in the relevant legal proceedings, he wrote. The court also faulted Meta for submitting partial documentation in highly technical language, for substituting the TSE's deadlines with its own, and for a lack of transparency.
In his ruling, Bellizze argued that digital platforms wield power over information through opaque algorithmic systems, influencing the spread of political information and voters' decision-making, and that the case showed how hard it is to enforce measures that depend on data only the company itself holds.
Meta pushed back. "Meta complies with Brazilian electoral law and applies the same rules to all candidates and parties," the company said in a statement reported by Reuters, adding that it would keep presenting the facts and defending itself in the ongoing proceedings against what it called unfounded allegations. In its statement it also said it would keep explaining the facts.
The decision is Meta's second setback in Brazil in a matter of days: a court in São Paulo has just barred the company from using media content to train its artificial intelligence.
Sources
- heise.deheise online — Geldstrafe gegen Meta in Brasilien
- g1.globo.comg1 (Globo) — TSE multa Meta: Relator vota por punição de R$ 7,5 milhões
- agenciabrasil.ebc.com.brAgência Brasil — TSE multa Meta em R$ 7,5 milhões por descumprir decisão nas eleições
- www1.folha.uol.com.brFolha de S.Paulo — TSE condena Meta a multa de R$ 7,5 mi por descumprimento




