SYDNEY — A bill written to keep children away from pornography may end up checking the age of every Australian who wants to read their email, Google told a Senate committee on Monday.
Rachel Lord, YouTube's public policy manager in Australia, said one section of the Digital Duty of Care bill could require Google to verify ages and block under-18s from 'everyday communication services like messaging, email and private file storage', The Sydney Morning Herald reported. Asked by Liberal senator Sarah Henderson whether Gmail and Google Drive could be forced to introduce age checks and scan private emails, messages and files, Lord answered: 'Correct.'
The mechanism is indirect. The clause covers any online service where there is a reasonably foreseeable risk that a child could come across pornography or fetish material. Where age assurance is technically feasible and reasonably practicable, providers must offer at least two ways of checking a user's age and stop anyone not verified as an adult from seeing that material. There is no exemption for email or messaging, and a breach carries the same maximum penalty as the duty itself: A$109.2 million.
Google supports a duty of care but wants that section confined to services whose sole or main purpose is distributing pornography. Communications Minister Anika Wells's office said it is 'not the government's intention to cut children off from email or the internet'. The bill passed the lower house on 28 October; the Senate committee is due to report by 20 November, and Wells wants the law passed by the end of the year, with the duty starting 12 months after that.
A second change has privacy advocates focused. A September draft listed privacy among the factors companies must weigh when complying. The current text does not; it names security and proportionality, and states that cost must not be considered. 'We're a bit confused about why it's been removed,' Lord said. 'There are no protections for Australian privacy when we're talking about what are effectively private communications and private file storage.'
Henderson called the bill 'deeply flawed' and said it would require companies such as Google 'to conduct mass surveillance of people's emails'. Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young used the hearing to press TikTok on enforcement: 'We actually need some proper rules in place because your community guidelines clearly aren't cutting it.'
The bill's broader purpose is a shift from complaint-and-takedown to a preventative duty: platforms must reduce foreseeable harm, with algorithm opt-outs for users and specific obligations around content that promotes eating disorders, misogyny, pornography, crime or dangerous challenges. Google, Meta, Snap and TikTok all appeared at Monday's hearing.
The practical question for the committee is whether an age-assurance trigger aimed at adult content can be written narrowly enough to exclude private communication — or whether the safest legal reading for a provider is to check everyone, everywhere, and lock out anyone it cannot verify.




