Before there were genes, there may have been reactions. That is the core of the metabolism-first theory of the origin of life, the subject of a Quanta Magazine explainer published as part of its Origins of Life Week.

The argument is thermodynamic. Without a self-sustaining reaction supplying energy, it is hard to explain how the larger, more complex molecules that cellular life depends on could have been assembled at all. Energy flowing through a system organizes it, the American biophysicist Harold Morowitz proposed in 1968 — an idea he applied specifically to a proto-metabolism.

A simple modern analogue is the acetyl-CoA pathway, which some microbes use to build organic molecules and harvest energy from hydrogen and carbon dioxide. In the late 1980s and early 1990s, the chemist Günter Wächtershäuser proposed an "iron-sulfur world" in which minerals around deep-sea hydrothermal vents catalyzed those reactions. William Martin, an evolutionary biologist at Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf, put it simply: "Energy going through the system is what life is in its many manifestations."

Lab work has moved the idea from speculation to something testable. In 2020, Martin and colleagues showed that carbon dioxide, hydrogen and nickel-iron minerals under vent-like conditions can produce formate, acetate and pyruvate — the spine of the acetyl-CoA pathway. Also in 2020, a Scripps Research team led by Ramanarayanan Krishnamurthy showed that pyruvate and glyoxylate can generate most components of the reverse citric acid cycle without metal catalysts and without vent-like extremes, suggesting metabolism could have started in a tepid pool rather than a deep-sea crucible.

Big gaps remain. Researchers still cannot explain how early metabolic reactions became stable enough to grow in complexity, and how they connected to the genetic machinery of inheritance. "How best can we mix them together so that we don't get a complete mess that we can't analyze? That is the challenge," Krishnamurthy said.

Editor's note: Quanta disclosed that Krishnamurthy has received funding from the Simons Foundation, which also funds the magazine.