For years, engineers at grid operators around the world watched a small, maddening signal: every 60 seconds, the frequency on their networks dipped a little, then recovered. The sags appeared in Europe, Australia, the United States and Malaysia — and they appeared at the same moment.

Germany's largest transmission system operator, TenneT, brought the puzzle to Dirk Witthaut, a researcher at Forschungszentrum Jülich. Solving it took years of measurement and modelling.

Why it matters: a grid runs on frequency. If oscillations grow too large, or operators respond wrongly because they do not know the cause, the result can be a blackout. Even when the sags cause no outage, they can damage equipment — especially hydropower turbines.

The obvious first suspect was hydropower. Every turbine vibrates, and at its resonant frequency those vibrations can reinforce each other: the wine glass shattering before an opera singer. Modelling a hydropower control system on the Scandinavian grid produced a resonance that peaked once a minute — but not one that persisted indefinitely. Real resonances come and go. This one did not.

Then came the realisation that anything keeping such perfect time needs a clock. The team installed more than 80 power-quality meters around the Jülich campus — on medium- and low-voltage lines, transformers, solar panels, battery storage and uninterruptible power supplies, plus a high-performance computer — sampling frequency, voltage, current and power every three seconds. The peak showed up on the transformer serving the battery energy storage system.

The culprit: stationary batteries, from data-centre UPS units to grid-scale battery farms, check their state of charge roughly once a minute. Because they are internet-connected, their clocks are synchronised to within milliseconds of each other. Individually the load blip is imperceptible. Collectively, it is a global metronome.

The evidence at scale came from Ireland, where data centres reached about 18% of electricity demand by 2022 and each facility runs fleets of UPS units. Between 2016 and 2021 the minute-by-minute dip on the Irish grid quadrupled, from 3 millihertz to 12 mHz; more recently some events have exceeded 20 mHz. Ireland's 50 Hz grid is built to withstand swings of plus or minus 200 mHz, and the operator would rather keep them within 100 mHz, so 20 mHz is not dangerous on its own. But the margin is shared, and data centres are not the only load on it.

The fix is almost embarrassingly small: randomise the polling schedule so the batteries no longer fire in unison. A software patch. But it requires coordination across manufacturers, operators and borders — and the same pattern is appearing in other always-on devices. The researchers detected periodic fluctuations from a smart oven and from Raspberry Pi clusters. A recent study found that less than 3% of IoT devices run the latest firmware, so patching the long tail will take years.

The mystery is solved; the metronome is still ticking. Regulators can only reach their own corner of an internet-synchronised fleet, which is why the authors argue the fix ultimately needs global coordination — and why the 60-second dip may be with us for a while.