On Friday, Germany's "Day of Open Data Centers", operators presented themselves as approachable service providers: guided tours, looks behind the scenes, a good deal of transparency rhetoric. Away from the German Datacenter Association's image campaign, the picture is different, according to reporting by public broadcaster SWR. Its data unit asked around thirty of the country's largest operators. More than half of those examined appear not to comply with their legal duty to publish electricity and water consumption figures — the numbers were simply not findable online. Some operators, the report says, explicitly refused to provide them, among them well-known names such as Equinix, NTT and CloudHQ.
The scale matters. According to the industry association Bitkom, data centres account for just under four percent of all German electricity consumption. Water comes on top — a lot of it depending on the cooling technology, at a time when groundwater levels are falling in many regions.
Germany's Energy Efficiency Act (EnEfG) demands openness for exactly this reason: operators of larger facilities must publish key figures on power and water use. Legal scholars consider the practice unlawful. Bernhard Wegener, a law professor in Erlangen, says the public plainly has a right to environmental information. Julian Bothe of AlgorithmWatch calls it fatal, in the middle of an energy and water crisis, to leave the exact scale of that resource hunger in the dark.
Companies invoke trade and business secrets. Equinix argues consumption data could allow conclusions about investment strategies or customer capacity, while insisting it meets all requirements. NTT points to exemptions in the EU Energy Efficiency Directive; the national German law contains no such blanket restriction. The responsible federal office, BAFA, stresses there are no agreements to exempt data from publication on trade-secret grounds.
The national data-centre register, launched online in the summer, is patchy too: of roughly one hundred of the largest facilities, only about a quarter are listed so far. Many firms do send their figures to the economics ministry but do not consent to public inspection — they are free to choose where to publish. The ministry has so far judged controls unnecessary.
At the same time the government wants the sector to grow, aiming to double data-centre capacity by 2030 to keep up internationally. Critics see a contradiction between that push and the missing transparency. And it could get worse: a planned reform of the EnEfG would explicitly exempt trade and business secrets from the publication duty. Bothe fears firms could then conceal even more easily how much energy is wasted through technical inefficiency. If the Bundestag passes the amendment, the ecological footprint of digital infrastructure will become even harder for the public to trace.




