Two sets of plaintiffs filed separate lawsuits against the AI music generator Suno on the same day, in the same court — the Northern District of California. One represents Elvis Presley. The other represents Eminem.

The Presley case is brought by a group that includes Authentic Brands Group and Raleigh Music Publishing. Its 51-page complaint accuses Suno of copyright infringement and of exploiting Presley's identity whenever users type his name to generate a song. But the load-bearing claim is different: that by letting users produce tracks mirroring Presley's "rich vocal timbre", Suno violated Tennessee's Ensuring Likeness Voice and Image Security Act — the ELVIS Act, a 2024 law.

That is the interesting part. The ELVIS Act was written to make voice cloning illegal as a matter of its own, separate from copyright. A plaintiff relying on it does not have to prove that a particular recording was copied. It has to show that a voice was reconstructed without permission. For an industry whose defence has rested on fair use and on the argument that models learn "like a person", that is a different and much less comfortable route through court.

Eight Mile Style, the publisher behind much of Eminem's catalog — "Lose Yourself", "Without Me", "The Real Slim Shady" among them — filed its own suit the same day, reportedly seeking more than $41 million. Eminem is not a party. Both cases are handled by the same lawyers: Richard Busch, Mark Block, David Niemierzycki and Andrew Davis.

The tone of the filings

The attorneys argue that Suno "mechanically encoded itself with artists' identities, hard-work, creativity, and time, and harnessed them all for a consistent conveyor belt of cold hard cash". The Presley complaint contains the line that will be quoted: "The next Elvis won't pick up a guitar." Suno, they write, is engaged in a "ravenous race to the bottom" to make human creativity obsolete, replicating in seconds without a licence what takes years to learn and maintain.

Both complaints include examples of generated songs that allegedly sound like Presley or reproduce Eminem's lyrics.

Suno's answer is the standing answer

"Suno exists to help people create new, original music, not to trade on anyone's name or likeness, and we prohibit any unauthorized use of an artist's work," spokesperson Cat McCormack said. The company does not allow prompts naming specific artists or songs, and works with third-party providers to screen uploaded audio and lyrics for misuse.

That defence has a known weakness, and the plaintiffs are already exploiting it. In the class action filed by Jason Isbell and other musicians in September, the claim was that users routed around the filters by describing an artist's "tone and phrasing" instead of naming them, or by inserting spaces between the letters of a name. Suno responded then that there was "nothing unlawful" about asking for a song in the vein of an artist.

This is already a portfolio, not a case

Suno is being sued by Universal Music Group, Sony Music, Round Hill Music and the Isbell group. Warner Music Group settled last year, and deals with WMG, BMG and Believe helped power the label-backed "v6" model that shipped in September. That same model generated another suit from UMG and Sony, which called it "the fruit of the same poisoned tree".

The context extends well past Suno. Authentic Brands sued Anthropic last month, claiming its chatbot was trained on 274 Presley songs including "Can't Help Falling in Love with You", and sought $48.6 million; Anthropic denies it. Eight Mile Style sued Meta in June for roughly $110 million over 243 of the rapper's recordings stored across its libraries; a federal judge in Michigan allowed that case to proceed into discovery.

And the market has shrugged. Suno raised $400 million in June at a $5.4 billion valuation.

Why this is more than another music spat

Three things are actually at stake. First, whether a voice is a sellable asset a state may protect even when copyright will not carry the case. The ELVIS Act is the first real test of that, and other states have passed or are considering similar statutes. A win hands every artist estate in the country a template. A loss keeps the argument permanently inside copyright law, where it has been stuck for three years.

Second, whether platform guardrails mean anything. Suno's defence is not about the technology but about the use — we forbid it, therefore it does not happen. If courts find that users can defeat the filter with a description or a space character, "we prohibit it" becomes a hard sentence to keep saying under oath.

Third, whether the record industry can make peace with Suno on licence terms while estates and publishers keep litigating. Warner did. Universal and Sony did, and then sued again over the model the deal helped build. That is not a legal framework; it is a negotiation conducted in courtrooms.

What to watch

Whether the ELVIS Act claim survives a motion to dismiss — that is the real fork in the road, and it will take months; whether Suno tries to move the case to a friendlier venue than Tennessee, where the statute bites; whether other estates follow now that Authentic Brands has shown the route; and whether a settlement with UMG and Sony discloses the price the industry actually wants for these voices. That number is what every one of these lawsuits is trying to discover.