The Independent Games Festival has never had an AI policy. It has one now, written in public, by the people who vote.

On 9 November a group of IGF jurors published a statement saying they will not vote for any game that used generative AI "in any capacity". The signatories include Sam Barlow, the designer behind Telling Lies and Immortality, and Lena Raine, who composed Celeste. The statement says this year's entries have been "incredible" but that there has been "a significant increase" in games developed with generative AI tools, producing "fairly intense discussion and disagreement" with no "universal consensus". Among the beliefs it lists: that generative AI has negative effects, that AI-generated code is "not an exception to these harms", and that the use of AI tools is "not a forgone conclusion in our industry".

The jurors were careful to say the statement speaks neither for the IGF as an organisation nor for every juror — and noted that some members worried about signing safely "without professional blowback". That is its own detail about how the discussion is going.

Within a day, the statement had a test case. House House, the studio behind Untitled Goose Game, published a statement to Aftermath and on its own site about its new co-op adventure Big Walk. It had used large language models "sparingly" in the game's "final stretch", to "help work through difficult technical challenges and bugs".

The specifics it gave are almost oddly small. "In some cases, snippets from LLM responses were copied as a starting point to be modified into game code — we'd estimate that well under 0.1% of Big Walk's code had anything to do with this usage, and generative AI was not used in any other context when making the game." The primary use, the studio said, was researching problems in third-party code through chatbots — including a shadow bug it had already investigated "extensively" and discussed with an engineer at Unity before getting a fix from an LLM and modifying it.

House House disclosed the usage in its IGF submission but not on Big Walk's Steam page, because, it said, the platform does not ask for disclosure of code or chatbot usage. It called the absence of an internal AI policy during development "a failure" and said it would write one. And it apologised: "This is not an endorsement of, or argument for, the use of AI tools, however minimal. We have some concern that voluntary disclosures like this might contribute to the normalisation of this technology, or its treatment as 'inevitable'."

That last sentence is the whole argument in miniature. A studio that did roughly the smallest possible thing — a handful of modified suggestions, well under a thousandth of the codebase — is worried that saying so out loud makes the practice normal. The jurors, meanwhile, have no enforcement mechanism; the IGF has no rule to apply; and the platforms that distribute games do not ask. What is being negotiated in public this week is not whether AI is used. It is whether disclosure can exist without becoming endorsement.