Alpha School, the for-profit company whose private campuses charge more than $50,000 a year for roughly two hours a day of AI-driven academics, tried to walk its model into a Massachusetts public middle school this fall. The pilot never ran.

Three days before Springfield students returned to class, a district technology official was asked by an Alpha representative to install new software on 30 school computers. "Do you happen to know whether the 'Alpha School' company has an agreement with [Springfield Public Schools]?" he wrote to the district's IT chief, in emails obtained by WBUR.

The plan, three months in the making at Kiley Prep inside the Springfield Empowerment Zone, ran out of runway. A data-sharing agreement was still under legal review in late August; an unsigned draft restricted how Alpha could use student information and barred training general-purpose models on personally identifiable data, but did not settle whether students would face screen recordings, webcam or microphone monitoring, or biometric collection — all listed in Alpha's broader privacy policy. Some families learned of the pilot the night before school started. The local NAACP raised concerns about parental consent and student privacy. Then a district-wide cyberattack closed schools for four days, and the pilot was cancelled.

The wider picture is more uncomfortable. Massachusetts Secretary of Education Stephen Zrike introduced Alpha to roughly a dozen superintendents in a June virtual presentation, telling them the model was "not without controversy" but "thought-provoking", and separately encouraged the Empowerment Zone's co-executive director to explore it. The state education department says such introductions are routine and that districts decide for themselves. The local teachers' union president, Riley Hernandez, said the scope surprised him. "Does he represent the interests of educators who do the work every day," he asked, "or the interests of ed tech, the interests of corporate profits, the interests of Alpha?"

Alpha says it has no public-school programme underway or in development in Massachusetts, and no plans to launch one soon. Several superintendents who joined the June call said they found the pitch interesting and declined anyway.